Clutch Puppy Picks
Better Picks. Always Free.
For the community. No fake locks.
Back to dashboard
YesterdayLine moved
MLB

New York Yankees logoNYY@CLECleveland Guardians logo

New York New York Yankees at Cleveland Cleveland Guardians · 6:40 PM ET
Share X Reddit
Predicted winner
CLE
Predicted final score
NYY 5 - CLE 3.5
Sportsbook line
+100
Implied probability
48%
from market price
Model probability
49%
our estimate
Value gap
+1 pts
model sees more value
Confidence
Final recommendation
Pass0.25u
Model pick · CLE +1.5 (-155)

Home no-vig implied moved from 44.9% to 47.8% (toward home).

"Biggest risk: statistical edge signal is against this side (-0.00). Variance and late line moves can flip a 53% read."

Clutch Puppy Expert Summary

Main prediction

This is a tight, low-edge MLB spot where the model slightly prefers Cleveland on the +1.5 at the available price: CLE +1.5 (-153). The model gives Cleveland a 45.9% win probability versus the market-implied 45.7%, producing a tiny value gap of 0.2%. The predicted run line outcome is NYY 4.8 - CLE 3.3 and the model’s strength score sits at 52%, so this is a modest, analytics-driven lean rather than a hammer.

Best bet
CLE +1.5 (-153) — Sportsbook line: +114
Projected final
NYY 4.8, CLE 3.3
Odds & line movement

The market opened 114/-134 and is currently 114/-125. Home no-vig implied moved from 44.9% to 45.7% (toward home), a small shift in favor of the home side but not a sweeping move.

Key matchups & handicap
Yankees Offense vs Guardians Run Prevention

New York profiles as the stronger offense on paper with Avg 5.1 scored · 3.6 allowed (season). Cleveland’s team scoring/allowing line sits at Avg 4.1 scored · 4.0 allowed (season), so this matchup projects a slight edge to NYY’s run creation, which the model reflects in the NYY 4.8 projection.

Recent Form & Records

Both teams have been solid this year: CLE is 37-30 while NYY is 38-26. Those records translate to similar quality over the season and help explain why the market and model are so close (Model 45.9 vs Market 45.7).

Hot/Cold Status

Season win rates are near each other — CLE has a 55% season win rate and NYY a 59% season win rate — indicating neither team is running away hot or freezing cold, which keeps this a tight, low-edge spot.

Predicted Run Environment

The model expects a modest scoring game (predicted score NYY 4.8 - CLE 3.3) which matches both teams’ season averages and suggests the run line (+1.5) is the cleaner play if you prefer limiting variance.

Top supporting factors
  • Model win prob 45.9% vs Market implied prob 45.7% gives a value gap of 0.2%.
  • Recent form: CLE record 37-30 with Avg 4.1 scored · 4.0 allowed (season); NYY record 38-26 with Avg 5.1 scored · 3.6 allowed (season).
  • Layer contributions include sharp_agreement contributing 0.012 in favor while statistical_edge contributes -0.001 against the pick.
  • Home no-vig implied moved from 44.9% to 45.7% per market signals (Opened 114/-134, current 114/-125).
Betting trends
  • CLE record 37-30
  • NYY record 38-26
  • CLE Avg 4.1 scored · 4.0 allowed (season)
  • NYY Avg 5.1 scored · 3.6 allowed (season)
  • CLE 55% season win rate
  • NYY 59% season win rate
  • Market opened 114/-134 and is currently 114/-125; home no-vig implied moved from 44.9% to 45.7%
NYY injuries & notes

No major injury notes detailed for this matchup.

CLE injuries & notes

No major injury notes detailed for this matchup.

Team & game total picks

Best bet - CLE +1.5 (-153) — small model edge (0.2%) driven by sharp_agreement contribution of 0.012 and a cleaner hedge against NYY’s higher scoring rate.

Total - No explicit total pick — the model’s predicted combined scoring (4.8 + 3.3) implies a low-to-moderate total and favors playing the run line if you want to limit variance.

Counterargument

The most realistic loss scenario is New York pushing the pace — the Yankees average 5.1 scored (season) and can exceed the model’s 4.8 projection, which would make Cleveland’s +1.5 too small to hold.

Injury concern

No reported injury impact.

Predicted score

The model’s NYY 4.8 - CLE 3.3 projection aligns with season scoring: CLE Avg 4.1 scored · 4.0 allowed (season) and NYY Avg 5.1 scored · 3.6 allowed (season), implying a slight edge to New York’s offense but a close overall total.

What this confidence rating means

The strength score of 52% reflects a very modest value gap (0.2%) between the model (45.9%) and the market (45.7%), so treat this as a low-confidence, positive-expected-value spot.

Final score prediction

This should play out as a close, lower-run game with New York generating slightly more offense but Cleveland keeping it within a run: final score projection NYY 4.8 - CLE 3.3. Final score: NYY 4.8 - CLE 3.3.

Final recommendation

Take CLE +1.5 (-153) as the top play while shopping lines; the model shows a small edge (0.2%) versus the market and the pick is supported by sharp agreement.

How to bet this game

Shop the price — the model recommends CLE +1.5 (-153) but list shows Sportsbook line +114, so check multiple books for the best +1.5 or better juice; consider taking the ML or alternate run line only if you can improve on the posted -153. Pair the run-line play with correlated small-stakes totals or single-game hedges if you need to reduce variance.

Top supporting factors

  • statistical edge (-0.003) - against pick
  • situational edge (0.000) - supports pick
  • sharp agreement (+0.046) - supports pick
  • market value (0.000) - supports pick

Counterargument

Biggest risk: statistical edge signal is against this side (-0.00). Variance and late line moves can flip a 53% read.

Injury impact

No reported impact.

Team status

  • CLE · neutral
    55% season win rate
  • NYY · neutral
    59% season win rate

Recent form (last 10)

  • CLE
    Avg 4.1 scored · 4.0 allowed (season)
    37-30
  • NYY
    Avg 5.1 scored · 3.6 allowed (season)
    38-26

Historical trends

    Line movement

    Model vs market

    Modelvs
    Marketvs

    Last updated 7d ago (6/9/2026, 10:30:46 PM)

    Strength percentages reflect model-estimated value vs market - not a guarantee of outcome. A 100% rating means the model sees roughly double the value of a toss-up. For research and entertainment.